More RHUBARB and less diet

Meaning & Analysis

The proverb advises consuming more rhubarb, a plant known for its strong laxative properties, while paying less attention to a controlled or restrictive diet. It prioritizes a purgative remedy over disciplined eating habits.

Insights

Quick Fixes vs. Discipline

The proverb metaphorically contrasts the appeal of quick, forceful remedies ('rhubarb') with the challenges of sustained, disciplined effort ('diet'). It serves as a critique of seeking easy solutions for problems that demand fundamental change and self-control.

Indulgence and Consequence

It can be interpreted as a cynical endorsement of an 'indulge and purge' lifestyle. Rather than preventing problems through careful living (diet), one simply addresses the consequences with a powerful, corrective action (rhubarb).

Action over Abstinence

The saying also highlights a preference for active intervention over passive restraint. 'Rhubarb' represents taking a tangible, even aggressive, step, whereas 'diet' signifies abstention and patience, making it a commentary on different approaches to problem-solving.

Historical Medical Context

The proverb is rooted in early modern medical practices where rhubarb was a common and potent purgative. It reflects the humoral theory of medicine, which advocated for purging to rebalance the body, contrasting this with the more modern concept of dietary control.

Psychology of Impatience

This saying captures a timeless human psychological tendency to prefer immediate, decisive (and often harsh) solutions over the sustained, difficult work of self-discipline. The 'rhubarb' represents a quick fix, while 'diet' symbolizes a long-term, arduous commitment.

Cynical Folk Wisdom

The single 1655 citation by Moffett dismisses it as an 'addle proverb' (a foolish one), suggesting it may have been a cynical or satirical folk expression rather than prescriptive wisdom. It likely mocked those who would rather indulge and then purge, than practice moderation.

Rhetorical Devices

Antithesis

The proverb's structure is built on the direct contrast between 'rhubarb' (a tangible, active cure) and 'diet' (a regimen of restraint), creating a memorable and stark choice.

Symbolism

'Rhubarb' functions as a symbol for any quick, potent, and perhaps unpleasant remedy, while 'diet' symbolizes the broader concept of long-term discipline, moderation, and self-control.

Conciseness

The phrase is exceptionally brief and blunt, which enhances its character as a piece of cynical, worldly advice, making it impactful and easy to recall.

healthdisciplineimpatienceremedycynicismmedicine

Analyzed with gemini-2.5-pro on July 1, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

(These addle proverbs .. More).

— 1655, MOFFETT, Health's Improvem., i, p. 8

Related Proverbs

L418 LONDONER-LIKE, ask as much more as you will take 90.3%P483 The PORPOISE (dolphin) plays before a storm 89.9%P605 PROMISES, like piecrust, are made to be broken 89.9%A39 Much ADO to bring beggars to the stocks 89.9%S41 On SAINT DISTAFF's DAY¹ partly work and partly play 89.7%A11 The ABUNDANCE of money ruins youth 89.5%A3 To bring an ABBEY to a grange 89.5%P479 To have a POPE in one's belly 89.4%L302 LINCOLNSHIRE, where hogs shit soap and cows shit fire 89.3%C500 His COCKLOFT is unfurnished 89.3%A403 A kindly AVER¹ will never make a good horse 89.2%F95 Your FATHER was no glazier 89.2%R161 A ROGUE's wardrobe is harbor for a louse 89.0%N140 He that brings good NEWS knocks boldly 88.9%A143 ALL is lost that is put in a riven dish 88.9%C181 CATS eat what hussies spare (what the goodwife spares) 88.8%N87 It had NEED be dainty, it cost him so dear 88.8%F424 Snotty FOLKS are sweet (wise) but slavering folks are weet¹ (kiss sweet) 88.8%C260 CHEAPSIDE¹ is the best garden 88.8%F625 Far FOWLS have fair feathers 88.8%

These connections are generated using word-embeddings. Learn more.