Meaning & Analysis
The small attic or storage space directly under the roof of a house is empty and contains no furniture.
Insights
Intellectual Vacancy
The proverb's primary meaning is that a person is unintelligent, foolish, or lacks common sense. The 'cockloft' serves as a metaphor for the head or brain, and its 'unfurnished' state signifies an intellectual void.
Deceptive Appearances
As the quotations illustrate, the proverb often implies that an impressive physical appearance, particularly height, can be deceptive, masking a lack of mental substance. It's a warning against judging a person's intellect by their stature.
Architectural Body Metaphor
The proverb uses the architecture of a house as a direct metaphor for the human body, where the highest, often least-functional, room (the cockloft) represents the mind. This reflects a common pre-modern worldview that explained the human form through familiar physical structures.
Historical Stereotype
The associated quotations from the 17th century reveal a specific historical prejudice that tall individuals are often less intelligent ('Tall Men are like high Houses... the uppermost Room is worst furnish'd'). The proverb served as a popular, concise expression of this folk stereotype.
Psychological Leveling
The saying functions as a form of social or psychological leveling. It humorously suggests that an imposing physical presence does not guarantee intelligence, serving to cut those who are physically impressive 'down to size' intellectually.
Rhetorical Devices
Metaphor
The entire proverb is a metaphor, where the 'cockloft' represents the mind and 'unfurnished' represents a lack of intelligence or thought.
Imagery
It creates a vivid, slightly comical image of a dusty, empty attic, which effectively and memorably conveys the concept of a vacant mind.
Euphemism
The phrase acts as a folksy and indirect way to call someone unintelligent, softening the insult through rustic imagery rather than direct language.
Transcription
Quotations
Sir, said Bacon, Tall Men are like high Houses of four or five Stories, wherein commonly the uppermost Room is worst furnish'd.
Often the Cockloft is empty, in those which nature hath built many stories high.
Edward the First .. was very high in stature. And though ofttimes such .. are observed to have little in their cock-loft, yet was he a most judicious man.
*He wants brains. Tall men are commonly like high houses, in which the uppermost room is worst furnished.
Related Proverbs
Original Scan
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.