He that gains HELL has made an ill market

Meaning & Analysis

Anyone whose choices end in damnation has struck a disastrously bad bargain—whatever was gained was not worth the price.

Insights

Profit at soul’s expense

Material or social winnings bought by corrupt means amount to a loss when the ultimate cost is one’s soul; the market metaphor frames vice as a ruinous overpayment.

False economy

Short-term advantage can mask catastrophic long-term cost. What seems shrewd in the moment proves, on final reckoning, an ‘ill market.’

Moral accounting

Actions are entries in a ledger; hell is the red ink that reveals hidden liabilities. The proverb urges audit of true costs, not just visible ‘profits.’

Ends vs. means

Gains achieved by unjust means invert value: success so defined is failure, because method contaminates outcome.

Mispriced desires

The heart can misvalue goods—honor, pleasure, coin—over integrity; the saying warns against appetites that distort one’s internal price list.

Biblical economy

It echoes Matthew 16:26—‘What is a man profited, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?’—translating salvation theology into shop-talk for merchants and householders.

Early modern mercantilism

In trading societies, moralists spoke in market idioms (gain, bargain, market) so prudence and piety could be heard in the vernacular of exchange.

Faustian bargain

Faust folklore dramatizes the proverb’s logic: a pact that secures knowledge, pleasure, or power but settles in damnation is the archetypal ‘ill market.’

Memento mori accounting

Death closes the books. The adage trains foresight to the ultimate audit, where deferred costs surface and apparent profits are written off.

Externalities of vice

Ill-gotten gains impose hidden harms—on others and on character. The proverb names the final externality: a self unfit for communion with the good.

Rhetorical Devices

Metaphor

Casting salvation in market terms (‘gain,’ ‘ill market’) turns theology into everyday economics, sharpening the lesson through familiar imagery.

Antithesis

‘Gains’ versus ‘ill market’ pits apparent profit against true loss, creating a neat moral reversal.

Paradox

Winning can be losing: the proverb hinges on the counterintuitive claim that success measured wrongly is failure.

Gnome (maxim)

A terse, proverbial sentence with immediate prescriptive force, suited to memorization and moral instruction.

Alliteration/Assonance

The hard g and l sounds (‘gains… ill’) give a clipped, ledger-like cadence befitting the language of accounts.

damnationgreedmoralaccountingtradeprudenceethics
Analyzed with gpt-5.0-thinking on December 20, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

1616, DR., Unfortunate, no. 2280

He that gaines hell comes to an ill bargaine.

1639, CL., p. 81

Original Scan

He that gains HELL has made an ill market - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026