On a good BARGAIN (pennyworth) think twice (pause a while)

Meaning & Analysis

When an offer seems very cheap or advantageous, do not rush—stop and reconsider before agreeing.

Insights

Suspicion of allure

Attractive terms often hide defects—shoddy quality, hidden fees, or compromised ethics. The proverb trains instinct to treat ‘too good’ as a warning label, not a green light.

Delay as wisdom

Time is a tool. A brief pause cools impulse, invites verification, and restores judgment; the bargain that survives scrutiny is the only true gain.

Ethical due diligence

Unusually low prices may signal goods ‘ill gotten’—stolen, sweated, or fraudulently acquired. Thinking twice includes asking whether the deal is right, not just cheap.

Winner’s curse

Beating others to an ‘amazing deal’ can mean you overestimated its value. The adage anticipates the auction-room trap where victories mask losses.

Self-control over present bias

Desire for a deal narrows attention to immediate savings. The proverb prescribes a cooling-off countermeasure against urgency, scarcity cues, and anchoring.

Pennyworth & provenance

‘Pennyworth’ signals a very cheap price; early glosses already pair this proverb with the warning that a ‘good bargain is a pickpurse.’ Traditional notes even caution that such wares may be ‘ill gotten,’ widening thrift into a moral inquiry.

Italian conduit, Anglo thrift

Collectors mark it ‘Ital.’, and later Franklin tightens it to ‘At a great pennyworth, pause a while’: a Mediterranean caution naturalized into Anglo-American common sense about markets and moderation.

Market psychology

‘Limited time’ and ‘deep discount’ frames exploit loss aversion and FOMO. The proverb counters with a simple protocol—insert delay—shifting the buyer from reflex to reflection.

Policy resonance

Modern ‘cooling-off’ laws and return windows institutionalize this folk wisdom: systems build formal pauses where sellers manufacture urgency.

Beyond shopping

The ‘bargain’ stands for any tempting commitment—partnerships, treaties, job offers. The same counsel holds: verify terms, sources, and downstream obligations before signing.

Rhetorical Devices

Imperative maxim

‘Think twice / pause a while’ delivers crisp, actionable counsel, easy to recall under pressure.

Paradox

What is ‘good’ demands hesitation; the tension jolts hearers out of complacency about cheapness.

Parallelism & balance

Short, paired phrases (‘good bargain’ / ‘think twice’) create mnemonic symmetry suited to quick deployment at the point of choice.

Metonymy

‘Bargain’ stands for agreements of all kinds, letting a market scene carry wide prudential force.

Allusive linkage

It implicitly invokes its sibling warning—‘a good bargain is a pickpurse’—enriching meaning through proverbial cross-reference.

prudencedue-diligencebehavioral-biasethicsconsumerismdecisionmaking
Analyzed with gpt-5.0-thinking on November 14, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

1640, HERB., no. 525

(twice, for a good bargain is a pick-purse)

1658, EDMONDSON, Comes Fac. in Via, p. 22

Think well upon't when thou art offered a good penniworth.

1659, HOW., It. Prov., p. 10
1659, N.R., p. 82
1664, COD., p. 208

At a good peny-worth, pause a little while.

1666, TOR., It. Prov., 35, p. 65

For there may be some fraud in the commodity, or in the person, as being ill gotten.

*Note, 36, p. 78

*Ital.

1670, RAY, p. 2
1705, Pleas. Art, p. 150

At a great pennyworth, pause a while.

1739, FRANKLIN, p. 15

Cross References

Original Scan

On a good BARGAIN (pennyworth) think twice (pause a while) - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026