Stolen FRUIT is (Stolen apples are) sweet

Meaning & Analysis

Fruit—or any treat—taken illicitly or in secret tastes especially sweet or enjoyable, simply because it is forbidden.

Insights

Attraction of the Forbidden

The proverb expresses the perennial truth that people often desire what they are denied, and forbidden acts or pleasures gain added appeal precisely because they are prohibited.

Transgressive Delight

It highlights the psychological thrill of breaking rules or defying authority, suggesting that the pleasure is heightened by the sense of risk or secrecy.

Illusion of Value

Implies that the sweetness of stolen fruit is illusory or fleeting; what is gained illicitly seems more desirable, but may not be truly more satisfying in the end.

Biblical and Cultural Resonance

The proverb echoes the biblical story of Eve and the forbidden fruit in Eden, symbolizing the universal allure of what is off-limits. The theme recurs in countless cultures, linking desire and prohibition.

Moral Ambiguity

Commentators have observed the proverb’s dual moral: while it acknowledges the irresistible pull of the forbidden, it also hints at the dangers and consequences of transgression—an ambivalence captured in many folk tales and literary works.

Psychological Truth

The saying captures a deep psychological truth: scarcity and prohibition intensify craving, and the thrill of subversion can temporarily outweigh caution or conscience.

Rhetorical Devices

Metaphor

Uses 'fruit' or 'apples' as a metaphor for all forbidden pleasures, making the lesson broadly applicable and vivid.

Paradox

Paradoxically, what should be less attractive because it is illicit becomes more attractive, a reversal that gives the proverb its pithy power.

Allusion

Alludes implicitly to biblical and classical traditions, enriching its meaning and universality.

forbiddendesiretemptationpsychologymoralitypleasure
Analyzed with gpt-4.1 on July 12, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

Dulce Pomum. Quum abeat custos . . This Prouerbe may be taken diuers waies: for it is either vsed, when wicked men beeing not punished, goe from one wickednesse vnto another: or els, when any thing is gotten from an other man, either by deceit, or other craftie meanes.

1580, BARET, D-1355

But as the Prouerbe hath it . . Apples are sweet, when they are plucked in the Gardeners absence. Eve liked no Apple in the Garden so well as the forbidden.

1614, T. ADAMS, Fatal Banquet III, Wks., p. 204

If they so highly valued stolne fruits, they would much more prize such as were lawfully enjoy'd.

1640, BRATHWAITE, Art Asleep Husb., p. 274

Cross References

Original Scan

Stolen FRUIT is (Stolen apples are) sweet - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026