Meaning & Analysis
Literally, the proverb equates fire with love and water with sorrow, associating each element with a distinct human emotion.
Insights
Elemental Emotions
Uses the contrasting properties of fire and water to represent passionate, consuming love (fire) and the cooling, often overwhelming nature of sorrow (water).
Oppositional Forces
Highlights the binary opposition between the uplifting, energizing power of love and the dampening, sorrowful effect of grief or sadness.
Historical Symbolism
Since antiquity, fire and water have been recurring symbols for the full range of human experience—fire for desire, warmth, or life; water for grief, tears, or loss. Greene’s 16th-century citation reflects this tradition, encoding emotional wisdom in elemental imagery.
Cultural and Literary Resonance
The proverb belongs to a rich literary heritage that personifies emotions as elements, a trope common from classical poetry to folk song. The opposition between fire and water dramatizes love’s power to enliven and sorrow’s tendency to quench or drown.
Psychological Dimensions
The proverb captures a basic truth about the emotional spectrum: love invigorates and animates (like fire), while sorrow exhausts and chills (like water). It acknowledges the tension and interplay between joy and grief in human life.
Rhetorical Devices
Metaphor
Directly equates fire with love and water with sorrow, transforming abstract feelings into concrete, sensory experiences.
Parallelism
Balanced, symmetrical structure enhances the clarity and memorability of the proverb’s message.
Antithesis
Juxtaposes the energizing qualities of fire/love against the depressive qualities of water/sorrow, heightening the emotional contrast.
Transcription
Quotations
If th’ old saw did not borrow, Fier is loue, and water sorrow.
Related Proverbs
Original Scan

Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.