Meaning & Analysis
The proverb literally advises allowing one malevolent entity (a devil) to strike or beat another, based on the archaic meaning of 'ding' as 'to beat'.
Insights
Conflict Between Foes
When two corrupt or hostile individuals or groups are in conflict, it is often wise to stay out of it and let them expend their energy fighting each other. Their mutual destruction can be to the observer's advantage.
Strategic Passivity
This proverb advocates for a strategic passivity. Rather than wasting one's own resources fighting two separate evils, one can allow them to neutralize each other, achieving a positive outcome through inaction.
Poetic Justice
The proverb embodies the concept of poetic justice, where evil ultimately becomes the instrument of its own demise. It suggests a natural order in which malevolence is self-consuming.
Pragmatic Non-Intervention
The proverb reflects a pragmatic, if cynical, worldview often found in folk wisdom. It suggests a strategy of non-intervention in the conflicts of malicious parties, a common theme in political and social strategy where an observer benefits from rivals weakening each other. This is the essence of 'realpolitik' applied to everyday life.
Psychology of Cynicism
Psychologically, the proverb captures a form of justified schadenfreude—the pleasure derived from seeing one's adversaries suffer, framed as a sensible, self-preserving tactic. It implies a moral judgment that certain individuals ('devils') are outside the bounds of empathy or aid.
Cultural Symbolism
The use of 'devil' as a metaphor for a wicked person draws on a deep cultural and religious history, immediately framing the conflict as one between two inherently evil forces. This removes any moral obligation to intervene or mediate, simplifying a complex situation into a battle of irredeemable foes.
Rhetorical Devices
Symbolism
The 'devil' is a powerful and universally understood symbol for a malicious or evil person, making the proverb's meaning instantly clear and impactful.
Alliteration
The repetition of the hard 'd' sound in 'Devil ding' creates a punchy, percussive effect that reinforces the idea of striking or beating, making the phrase memorable.
Diction
The use of the simple, forceful verb 'ding' (to beat) gives the proverb a raw, vernacular energy that is more striking than a more common synonym like 'fight' or 'hit'.
Transcription
Quotations
Gar [make] ane devill ding ane other.
*Spoken when two bad Persons quarrel.
Annotations
- beat
Related Proverbs
Original Scan

Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.