They that are whole need not a PHYSICIAN, but they that are sick

Meaning & Analysis

Those who are healthy have no need of a physician; only those who are ill require medical help.

Insights

Appropriateness of Aid

The proverb serves as a metaphor for the allocation of help or intervention, emphasizing that assistance should be directed toward those who genuinely need it, not those who are already well-off or self-sufficient.

Recognition of Need

It also represents the importance of acknowledging one's own shortcomings or vulnerabilities—healing, improvement, or guidance can only occur when there is an admission of need.

Spiritual and Moral Application

In its biblical context, the saying is often applied to spiritual or moral situations: those who see themselves as righteous may not seek transformation, while those aware of their faults are receptive to growth and redemption.

Biblical Origin and Usage

Originating from Mark 2:17, the proverb is famously used by Jesus to explain his association with sinners and the marginalized. Its scriptural roots have made it a lasting metaphor for humility and the universality of human need.

Social and Psychological Wisdom

The proverb recognizes a psychological truth: those blind to their own issues resist help, while openness to weakness is the first step toward healing, whether physically, emotionally, or morally.

Universal and Cross-Cultural Resonance

Similar expressions appear in diverse languages and literatures, highlighting the timeless insight that aid is meaningful only where it is needed—an idea reflected in medicine, charity, and education alike.

Rhetorical Devices

Antithesis

The proverb’s power lies in its clear opposition between 'whole' and 'sick,' reinforcing the logic of need and suitability.

Biblical Parallelism

The balanced, parallel structure characteristic of biblical language enhances clarity, rhythm, and memorability.

Universalization

Use of the impersonal 'they that are...' grants the saying a broad, universal application, transcending context.

needhelphumilitybiblicalrecognitionguidance
Analyzed with gpt-4.1 on July 10, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

They that be hole nedeth no physycyen, but a phisycyen is nedefull vnto them that be seke.

1508, J. FISHER, Sayings David in Psalms, p. 14

Christe, that sayeth . . The whole neede not a phisition, but they that are sicke.

c.1577, NORTHBROOKE, Treat. agst. Dicing, p. 22

Il sano non ha bisogna del medico.

1597, BRETON, Physician's Letter in Will Wit, Wks., II 62

The sicke haue neede of the Physician.

1616, DR., no. 1974

The sound man needs no Physician.

1620, SHELTON, Don Quix. Pt. II, xxii, III 166

(They that be whole).

1630, T. ADAMS, Physic from Heav., Wks., p. 290

Bible Citations

They that are whole have no need of the physician, but they that are sick.

— The Bible, Mark ii:17

Shakespeare Citations

I will not cast away my physic but on those that are sick.

AYL, III.ii

Original Scan

They that are whole need not a PHYSICIAN, but they that are sick - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026