Meaning & Analysis
The proverb is a simile comparing a person's sadness to that of a 'gibbed' or castrated male cat, which was believed to be particularly sullen, listless, and melancholy as a result of the procedure.
Insights
Loss of Vitality
The proverb serves as a metaphor for a profound sadness that stems from a loss of vitality, virility, or essential spirit. The castration symbolizes a fundamental alteration that leads to a state of enduring depression or powerlessness.
Forced Submissiveness
It can describe a state of being tamed or subdued against one's will. The cat's melancholy represents the psychological consequence of having one's natural instincts or freedom forcibly removed, leading to a quiet and deep-seated unhappiness.
Quiet, Brooding Sadness
The simile can be used to describe a specific type of quiet, withdrawn, and solitary sadness. It contrasts with more expressive forms of grief, highlighting an introspective and brooding form of melancholy.
Historical Animal Symbolism
The term 'gibbed cat' refers to a castrated male cat, linking the animal's perceived sullenness directly to its emasculation. This reflects a historical fascination with the connection between physical vitality and emotional disposition, particularly concerning masculinity and power.
Psychology of Melancholy
The proverb offers a psychological insight into the nature of melancholy as a state of quiet, brooding listlessness resulting from a significant loss of power or spirit. Unlike more active forms of grief, this sadness is characterized by withdrawal and passivity.
Literary and Cultural Context
Used by Shakespeare and his contemporaries, this simile was a common cultural reference for profound sadness. Its specificity—referring not just to any cat, but a 'gibbed' one—would have evoked a clear image of tamed wildness and subdued energy for audiences of the time.
Rhetorical Devices
Simile
The proverb is structured as a direct comparison using 'as...as' to equate a human emotional state with the perceived state of an animal.
Archaic Diction
The use of the archaic term 'gibbed' firmly places the proverb in its historical context (primarily the 16th and 17th centuries), lending it a specific period flavor.
Anthropomorphism
The proverb attributes the complex human emotion of melancholy to a cat, interpreting its quiet or aloof behavior through a human psychological lens.
Transcription
Quotations
I am as melancholy as a cat.
(as a cat).
(as a cat).
An thou hadst been wise, thou mightest have kept thee at home with thy melancholy cat.
A crabbed (cankerd) fellow: as melancholly as a cat.
Yonder he lies, and as melancholy as a Cat in a Church-Steeple, expecting my return.
Shakespeare Citations
I am as melancholy as a gib-cat.
Cross References
Related Proverbs
Original Scan
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.