Meaning & Analysis
The phrase is a pun. Literally, 'simples' were medicinal herbs, so one could be sick from them. However, the intended meaning is that a person is suffering from the 'illness' of being a 'simple' or foolish person (a simpleton).
Insights
Lovesickness as Folly
Describes a state of being foolishly or hopelessly in love. The lovesick individual is seen as acting simple-minded, and their condition is humorously diagnosed as an ailment.
Feigned Illness or Laziness
Functions as a sarcastic diagnosis for someone who is not genuinely ill but is lazy, idle, or feigning sickness to avoid duties. Their 'sickness' is a lack of wit or motivation.
Innate Foolishness
Refers to a person's inherent or chronic state of foolishness or naivety. It suggests that their simple-mindedness is a fundamental, unchangeable part of their character, like a chronic disease.
Historical Medical Pun
The proverb cleverly plays on the historical meaning of 'simples' as medicinal herbs. By framing foolishness as a 'sickness' treatable only by 'simples' (i.e., more simplicity), it reflects a pre-modern, humoral understanding of character, where personal traits were often described in medical terms.
Psychological Diagnosis
This phrase functions as a form of social critique, using medical language to humorously pathologize and dismiss behavior considered foolish, irrational, or lazy. It's a witty insult that frames a character flaw as an incurable, innate 'illness'.
Literary Wit
The expression is characteristic of the linguistic playfulness found in Renaissance and Elizabethan literature, where puns and double meanings were highly valued. It serves as a sophisticated, ironic commentary on human nature.
Rhetorical Devices
Pun / Wordplay
The proverb's core is the pun on 'simples', which means both basic medicinal herbs and a simple-minded or foolish person.
Irony
It is ironic to diagnose a character flaw (being a simpleton) using the language of medicine, treating foolishness as a literal illness.
Metaphor
The state of being simple-minded is metaphorically framed as a disease or sickness, creating a vivid and humorous image.
Transcription
Quotations
Related Proverbs
Original Scan

Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.