He has sold a BEAN and bought a pea

Meaning & Analysis

He traded something larger and more valuable (a bean) for something smaller and less valuable (a pea), making a worse exchange.

Insights

Bad bargain

Highlights a foolish or disadvantageous trade—giving up more to receive less—whether in money, status, information, or opportunity.

False economy

Warns against decisions that appear thrifty but erode overall value, such as skimping on essentials and paying more later.

Decline by choices

Signals a pattern of self-inflicted downgrades; each choice shrinks one’s position through shortsighted calculation.

Misjudged value

Critiques poor discernment—confusing price with worth, quantity with quality, or immediate gain with long-term benefit.

Moral-civic loss

Suggests a squandering of inherited advantages—selling a birthright of resources or reputation for a trifle.

Everyday economics

Beans and peas are humble staples; setting them in contrast makes loss legible through household trade. The proverb reproaches an unthrifty person whose dealings habitually diminish value.

Descending tricolon

An early citation pairs this line with “sold a pound and bought a penny” and “sold Bristol and bought Bedminster,” staging a comic cascade of downgrades—from commodity, to currency, to civic status—to dramatize folly.

Biblical echo

It resonates with Esau’s bargain—trading a birthright for a meal—exchanging something substantial for a fleeting trifle, a cautionary emblem of unwise appetite.

Psychology of ‘cheap’

The saying anticipates modern findings on false economy and the denomination effect: the lure of a ‘deal’ or small denomination blinds one to absolute loss.

Cross-cultural kin

Parallels include “penny wise, pound foolish” and Franklin’s “He paid too much for his whistle,” all satirizing prudence that misfires by fixating on the small while forfeiting the large.

Rhetorical Devices

Antithesis

Opposes larger-to-smaller, valuable-to-trivial, sharpening the moral of loss through stark contrast.

Concrete metaphor

Uses familiar foods as tokens of value, translating abstract economic misjudgment into a graspable image.

Alliteration

The b/p burst in “bean…bought…pea” and, in expansions, “pound…penny,” gives the proverb a catchy, mocking snap.

Bathos (comic descent)

The pattern of trading down creates a deliberate anticlimax that ridicules the agent’s judgment.

unthriftinessbadbargainfalseeconomyfollyvaluation
Analyzed with gpt-5.0-thinking on November 14, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

Hee hath sold a beane and bought a peaze; hee hath sould a pound and bought a penny; hee hath sold Bristoll and bought Bedminster.

c1640, SMYTH, 29, p. 29

Annotations

  1. Reproaches to an unthrifty man.

Original Scan

He has sold a BEAN and bought a pea - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026