Meaning & Analysis
The proverb ironically suggests that schoolboys are the most sensible people because they are perfectly happy to receive very little education in return for the tuition money their parents spend.
Insights
Critique of Immaturity
The proverb uses the schoolboy as a metaphor for immaturity and a lack of foresight. It illustrates how those who do not bear the cost of an investment often fail to appreciate its value, prioritizing immediate ease over long-term gain.
Subjective Value
It explores the subjective nature of 'value'. From a parent's perspective, value is knowledge acquired. From the schoolboy's perspective, value is freedom from work. The proverb satirizes the latter viewpoint by ironically calling it 'reasonable'.
Apathy and Wasted Potential
The saying serves as a broader social commentary on laziness and the squandering of opportunities. The schoolboy represents anyone who is content with mediocrity and is unconcerned with making the most of the resources given to them.
Generational Conflict
This proverb captures the timeless tension between parental investment and youthful indifference. It reflects a historical and ongoing social dynamic where one generation pays for opportunities that the next generation may not yet have the maturity to value, highlighting a fundamental conflict in long-term versus short-term perspectives.
The Economics of Opportunity
The proverb serves as a sharp commentary on the economic concept of value. By ironically framing schoolboys as 'reasonable' for not caring what they get for their money, it satirizes anyone who fails to appreciate or properly utilize a valuable resource that has been provided for them at another's expense.
Psychology of Youth
Psychologically, the proverb points to the principle of delayed gratification. Youthful minds often prioritize immediate pleasure (idleness) over abstract future rewards (the benefits of education), a key aspect of developmental psychology. The schoolboy's 'reasonableness' is a logic governed by immediate desire, not long-term planning.
Rhetorical Devices
Irony
The central device is irony, as the proverb calls a profoundly unreasonable attitude—not caring about getting value for money—'the reasonablest'. This satirical inversion is the source of its wit and meaning.
Hyperbole
The phrase 'the reasonablest people in the world' is a clear exaggeration that highlights the absurdity of the schoolboys' perspective, making the satirical point more forceful and memorable.
Paradox
The proverb presents a paradox by framing irrational economic behavior as the height of reason, forcing the audience to contemplate the different, conflicting logics of the parent and the child.
Transcription
Quotations
As Children, who play the Truant most willingly and who are said in England to be Conscientious Persons, they care not how little they have for their Money, so they may be idle, they care not what Charges their Parents be at.
Related Proverbs
Original Scan
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.