Meaning & Analysis
The person being described is as honest as any other human being who has ever lived, with the act of 'breaking bread' or eating serving as a fundamental definition of a living person.
Insights
Universal Benchmark of Integrity
The proverb establishes a universal benchmark for integrity. 'Breaking bread' is a common act shared by all humanity, suggesting the person's honesty is a fundamental, relatable, and universally recognizable virtue.
Honesty as Social Communion
Sharing a meal is a sign of fellowship, trust, and community. The proverb implies that the person's character is so reliable that they are worthy of the basic trust inherent in the act of communion with others.
Inherent and Natural Virtue
The phrase connects the abstract quality of honesty to a tangible, physical act of life. This suggests that the person's integrity is an inseparable part of their being, as essential and natural as life itself.
Sacramental and Social Honesty
The phrase 'broke bread' carries strong biblical and sacramental overtones, alluding to the Last Supper and the act of communion. This historical symbolism elevates the person's honesty, framing it not just as a social virtue but as a deeply moral and trustworthy quality worthy of fellowship.
Embodied Integrity
The proverb grounds the abstract virtue of integrity in the universal, life-sustaining act of eating. This connection suggests that the person's honesty is not a superficial trait but a fundamental, essential part of their character, as natural and necessary as nourishment.
Populist Virtue
By using a simple, everyday action as the benchmark for honesty, the proverb champions the integrity of the common person. It suggests that true virtue is found in fundamental human decency rather than in rank or status, reflecting a populist or egalitarian worldview.
Psychology of Commensality
The act of sharing a meal ('commensality') is a foundational social bond built on mutual trust. The proverb leverages this deep cultural resonance to imply that the individual is a reliable and safe member of the community, fit for fellowship and trust.
Rhetorical Devices
Simile
The proverb is a simile that compares an abstract quality (honesty) to a concrete, universal action ('broke bread'), making the compliment both profound and easily understood.
Symbolism
The phrase 'broke bread' serves as a powerful symbol for life, community, and fellowship. It elevates a simple act into a representation of all that is fundamental and trustworthy in human experience.
Hyperbole
The statement is a form of gentle hyperbole, claiming the person's honesty is equal to the most honest person who has ever lived. The everyday imagery keeps the grand compliment grounded and sincere.
Transcription
Quotations
You are as good a man as . . ere broke bread, or drunke drinke.
Truly I see you are your Mother's daughter, franke and free hearted, oh she was a good creature as broke bread.
My father was a Baker . . as honest a man as ever lived by bread.
No ravishers . . but two as honest as e'er broke bread.
Shakespeare Citations
An honest soul, i' faith, sir . . as ever broke bread.
An honest maid as ever broke bread.
Related Proverbs
Original Scan
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.