Meaning & Analysis
This is a superlative statement declaring that a man is of the highest possible quality, as excellent as any other living person on Earth. The variations 'as steps' or 'as treads the grass down' emphasize that the comparison is to any human who walks the earth.
Insights
Pinnacle of Human Excellence
The proverb establishes a universal standard of excellence. The man's goodness is not just commendable but is positioned as the pinnacle of human virtue, measured against all of humanity.
Innate Goodness
By linking goodness to the earth and the simple act of walking, the proverb suggests an innate, unpretentious, and fundamental virtue. It implies a character that is naturally and effortlessly good, rather than one performing virtuous acts.
The Ideal of the Common Man
The phrase 'as treads the grass down' democratizes the ideal of a 'good man'. It suggests that the highest virtue is not confined to heroes or kings but can be found in any ordinary person, grounding the ideal in common humanity.
Natural Virtue
The proverb's connection to the earth ('earth bears') evokes a sense of foundational, life-giving goodness. This grounds the individual's virtue in the natural world, suggesting their quality is as fundamental and reliable as the earth itself.
Folkloric Idealism
This form of superlative praise is common in folklore and epic literature to establish a character as an archetypal hero. The variations, such as 'treads the grass down', bring this epic scale to a more humble, relatable level, celebrating the potential for greatness in the common person.
Psychology of Archetypes
The proverb reflects a psychological need for clear moral exemplars. By framing goodness in such absolute terms, it serves to create an unambiguous ideal, a benchmark for admirable human character that simplifies complex moral realities.
Rhetorical Devices
Hyperbole
The proverb uses hyperbole, an intentional exaggeration, to emphatically praise a person's character beyond realistic measure, thereby conveying the highest degree of admiration.
Simile
The phrase 'as good a man as' functions as a simile, comparing the individual to the ultimate standard: the best man the entire earth can produce.
Imagery
The variations 'treads the grass down' and 'steps' employ simple, kinetic imagery to ground the abstract concept of 'goodness' in the physical, relatable action of a living person.
Transcription
Quotations
(as treads the grasse doune)
(as steps)
I know you are as good a man as . . ere trode on Gods earth.
Related Proverbs
Original Scan

Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.