That is GOLD which is worth gold

Meaning & Analysis

Something can only be considered genuine gold if it possesses the actual, verifiable value of gold. It defines authenticity through intrinsic worth.

Insights

Substance over Appearance

The proverb argues that true value, whether in objects, ideas, or people, is determined by its inherent substance and utility, not by superficial appearances or labels.

Authenticity and Character

It suggests that a person's true character and integrity—their 'gold'—are proven by their actions and their demonstrable worth to others, not by their reputation or self-proclamation.

The Test of True Worth

The proverb implies that anything of supposed value must be able to withstand scrutiny or a 'test'. Its worth is not a given but must be proven, just as metal is assayed to confirm it is real gold.

Economic and Material Reality

The proverb reflects a pre-fiat currency worldview where value was intrinsically tied to a physical commodity. The ability to exchange something for gold, as mentioned in the 1655 quotation, was the ultimate test of its worth, grounding the concept of value in a tangible, universally accepted standard.

Philosophical Counterpoint

This proverb is the philosophical inverse of 'All that glitters is not gold'. While the latter warns against false appearances, this one provides a positive definition of true worth, asserting that substance, not surface, is the final arbiter of value.

Psychology of Discernment

The proverb serves as a psychological principle for cutting through deception. It encourages a healthy skepticism, urging an assessment based on demonstrable, intrinsic qualities rather than accepting things at face value, whether in commerce, relationships, or ideas.

Rhetorical Devices

Tautology

The repetition of 'gold' creates a tautological loop ('X is X') that gives the statement an air of irrefutable, self-evident truth.

Symbolism

'Gold' serves as a powerful, universal symbol for ultimate value, purity, and authenticity, extending the proverb's meaning beyond the metal itself.

Parallelism

The balanced, parallel structure ('That is GOLD' / 'which is worth gold') makes the phrase rhythmic, emphatic, and highly memorable.

valueauthenticitysubstancetruthskepticismappearance

Analyzed with gemini-2.5-pro on July 16, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

'Tis Gold thats worth Gold.

— 1611, COT., s.v. Or

— 1640, HERB., no. 835

We say that is gold which is worth gold, which we may anywhere exchange for gold.

— 1655-1662, GURNAILL, Chr. in Armor, p. 381

— 1658, EDMONDSON, Comes Fac. in Via, p. 20

('Tis gold which).

— 1659, HOW., Fr. Prov., p. 10

— 1659, N.R., p. 114

— 1666, TOR., It. Prov., 18, p. 179

Related Proverbs

M805 MEASURE is treasure 83.6%M257 A MAN may buy gold too dear 83.3%W546 Bought WIT is dear 83.2%S960 That SUIT is best that best fits me 83.0%G93 Goose GIBLETS are good meat, old sack better than new 82.9%R85 A good REPUTATION is a fair estate 82.8%J43 True JESTS are the worst 82.7%G103 What is freer than GIFT? 82.6%H36 Better HALF a loaf than no bread 82.6%M993 MIRTH without measure is madness 82.5%R82 To buy REPENTANCE too dear 82.5%M1296 Whoso makes MUCH of thee that was not wont either will deceive or stands in need of thee 82.4%W924 The WORTH of a thing is best known by the want 82.4%T448 As the TOUCHSTONE tries gold, so gold tries men 82.3%S940 Great STROKES make not sweet music 82.3%B788 Let the BUYER beware 82.3%C669 It will not (will) quit the COST 82.0%E152 To speak plain ENGLISH 82.0%B607 His old BRASS (cloak) will buy you a new pan (kirtle) 81.9%E194 He that is EVERYWHERE is nowhere 81.9%

These connections are generated using word-embeddings. Learn more.