Meaning & Analysis
Literally, the proverb equates three things—fire made from flax, the love of a 'quean' (prostitute or promiscuous woman), and a gust of wind from the tail (flatulence or fleeting breeze)—declaring them to be the same in nature.
Insights
Ephemeral Nature
Alludes to the brief, intense, and quickly vanishing character of certain phenomena—specifically, that some things flare up quickly and then disappear just as fast.
Lack of Substance
Suggests that what appears impressive or passionate at first (whether in love, fire, or boast) often proves insubstantial and unreliable upon closer experience.
Fickleness and Deceit
Warns against trusting in things that are showy but transient—passionate but faithless love, empty promises, or superficial excitement.
Historical Symbolism
Flax burns rapidly and with great brightness, but immediately dies out; similarly, the proverb characterizes the love of a 'quean' as passionate but short-lived. This analogy was popular in European folklore, as seen in French ('amour de putain feu d'estoupe') and Spanish variants.
Cultural and Literary Resonance
The saying recurs in collections of proverbs, emphasizing the common folk wisdom that cautions against placing hope or trust in things that are, by nature, fleeting. It uses earthy imagery—fire, sex, and wind—for comedic and didactic effect.
Psychological Dimensions
Points to the human tendency to be dazzled by the immediate or flashy, and the subsequent disappointment when such excitement proves hollow. It’s a warning against gullibility and self-deception in matters of love, luck, or enthusiasm.
Rhetorical Devices
Tricolon
Employs a series of three vivid, earthy images to drive home the sense of equivalence and reinforce the proverb’s memorability.
Simile and Analogy
Draws direct analogies between disparate things (fire, love, wind) to communicate their common ephemeral quality.
Earthy Imagery
The use of rustic, sensory, and even bawdy imagery creates humor, immediacy, and a touch of cynicism.
Transcription
Quotations
Amour de putain feu d'estoupe: Pro. (Th' exposition followes) qui luit fort, et dure peu.
Fire of flax; loue of a queane, wind from the tayle, and such hopes, all are one.
The love of a quean like fire of flax.
The love of a Punk, the fire of flax, and the wind of the tail is one and the same thing.
Related Proverbs
Original Scan

Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.