Meaning & Analysis
Literally, the phrase describes someone with short heels on their shoes, which could make them physically unstable and prone to tipping or falling backward.
Insights
Unchastity and Promiscuity
The primary metaphorical meaning is that a woman is unchaste, promiscuous, or morally lax. The physical act of 'falling backward' serves as a direct and widely understood euphemism for sexual promiscuity.
Moral Instability
Beyond sexuality, the term signifies a general lack of moral grounding or steadfastness. A 'short-heeled' person is fickle, easily swayed, and unreliable in character, liable to 'fall' from virtue with little persuasion.
Flightiness and Fickleness
The phrase can also imply a general flightiness or lack of seriousness. It suggests a person who is not well-grounded, either in their principles or their commitments.
Physiognomy and Morality
The proverb is a powerful example of historical physiognomy, the belief that physical attributes reflect moral character. The physical instability suggested by short heels was metaphorically mapped onto a perceived lack of moral and sexual control, particularly in women.
Gender and Social Control
This is a distinctly gendered insult, reflecting societal anxieties about female sexuality and autonomy. By framing promiscuity as a physical deficiency ('short-heeled'), the proverb served as a tool of social control to enforce chastity and condemn women who deviated from prescribed norms.
Psychological Framing
The imagery of being easily 'blown over' or 'falling backwards' reveals a psychological tendency to frame female sexual agency as a passive failing or inherent weakness rather than an active choice. This diminishes female autonomy and reinforces patriarchal moral standards.
Rhetorical Devices
Metaphor
The entire proverb functions as a metaphor, translating the physical concept of instability from having short heels into the abstract concept of moral or sexual instability.
Euphemism
The phrase, particularly the implied action of 'falling backwards', is a thinly veiled euphemism for sexual activity, allowing for indelicate accusations to be made with indirect language.
Synecdoche
The 'heel', a small part of the body, is used to represent the entirety of a person's moral character and sexual conduct.
Transcription
Quotations
But her hed so gydy and her helys so shorte.
So short of heel they be ouer all, That if ye blowe they must needs fall.
I haue no fault but one, I am somewhat short in the heele.
Some shalbe so short heeld and so quesie stomackt that they shal ly in their beds while noon.
Hie she was in the instep, but short in the heele.
Mistresse flirt, you foule strumpet, Light aloue, shorte heeles, mistresse Gourfey.
Be not short-heeld with euery wind to fall.
Are ye so short heeld?
Take heed you play not at Tray-trip, Shorte heeles forsooth will quickly slip.
Surely she wears low-heel'd Shoes, she's apt to fall backwards.
Cross References
Related Proverbs
Original Scan

Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.