No PLAYING with (It is ill to draw) a straw before an old cat

Meaning & Analysis

It is pointless or unwise to try to amuse or deceive an experienced (old) cat by drawing a straw before her; older or wiser individuals are not easily fooled by simple tricks.

Insights

Wisdom and Experience

The proverb metaphorically expresses that the experienced are less susceptible to deception or manipulation; age and experience bring discernment and caution.

Futility of Deceit

It warns that attempts to trick, distract, or amuse someone who has seen much of life are likely to fail, as they recognize such ploys for what they are.

Historical Symbolism

The proverb draws on the familiar behavior of young animals versus old—young cats will chase a straw out of curiosity, but old ones remain unmoved. The image has roots in both fable and folk wisdom, underscoring respect for age and the limitations of cunning.

Cultural Resonance

Similar proverbs appear in many cultures, emphasizing the universal association of age with immunity to simple tricks and the broader skepticism of elders toward youthful antics.

Psychological Dimensions

The saying acknowledges the development of skepticism, critical thinking, and emotional resilience with age, affirming that maturity involves learning to recognize and resist manipulation.

Rhetorical Devices

Animal Metaphor

Using the 'old cat' as a stand-in for a wise or worldly person adds humor, familiarity, and vividness to the proverb’s caution.

Irony

There is gentle irony in the contrast between the simplicity of the 'straw' and the sophistication of the 'old cat,' highlighting the gap between naive tricks and experienced wisdom.

Personification

The proverb endows the cat with human-like sagacity, reinforcing the idea that wisdom is recognizable even in the animal world.

experiencewisdomdeceitagediscernmentmetaphor
Analyzed with gpt-4.1 on July 10, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

Thow wenis to Draw the stra befoir the catt!

1570, HENRYSON, Wolf and Neck-Herring, Fab., p. 148
1546, HEY., II viii, s. K2v

(It is ill to draw).

a.1598, FERG., MS, no. 825
1611, DAV., Prov., no. 262

(It is ill to draw).

1668, R.B., p. 31

I am o'er old a Cat, to draw a Straw before my Nose.

1721, KEL., p. 180

Annotations

  1. I am too old to be imposed upon. A young Cat will jump at a Straw drawn before her, but not an old one.

Original Scan

No PLAYING with (It is ill to draw) a straw before an old cat - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026