Meaning & Analysis
Literally, the proverb equates God with the qualities of a good, just, and reliable human male. It is a simple, direct statement of faith in God's benevolence, expressed in everyday, anthropomorphic terms.
Insights
Relatable Divinity
The proverb makes the abstract theological concept of divine benevolence accessible and personal. By calling God a 'good man', it translates omnibenevolence into relatable human virtues like kindness, fairness, and trustworthiness.
Moral and Cosmic Order
The phrase suggests a belief in a just and ordered universe. If the ultimate power is a 'good man', it implies that righteousness and fairness are foundational principles of existence, offering reassurance that virtue will ultimately be upheld.
Simplicity of Faith
It reflects a simple, unadorned form of piety, free from complex theological doctrine. It is a straightforward declaration of faith from the heart, accessible to all regardless of education.
Religious Anthropomorphism
This proverb is a classic example of religious anthropomorphism, making the abstract concept of divine goodness tangible and relatable to the common person by framing it in familiar, human terms.
Literary and Folkloric Context
Its use in popular literature, from the tales of Robin Hood to Shakespeare's comedic character Dogberry, illustrates its place in the popular vernacular. In 'Much Ado About Nothing', Dogberry's line 'Well, God's a good man' uses the phrase to underscore his simple, earnest, and un-sophisticated nature.
Psychological Comfort
The phrase offers psychological comfort by portraying the ultimate cosmic authority not as a distant, abstract entity, but as a reliable, just, and approachable figure, thereby reducing existential fear.
Linguistic Evolution
The explanation 'An old phrase for "God is good"' signals a linguistic and theological evolution. As religious language became more formal and abstract, this homely expression was relegated to a more rustic or archaic status.
Rhetorical Devices
Anthropomorphism
The core rhetorical device is anthropomorphism, attributing human form and virtuous character ('a good man') to the divine to make it understandable and relatable.
Declarative Simplicity
The phrase is a simple declarative sentence. Its power lies in its directness and lack of complex theological jargon, making it a confident and reassuring statement of faith.
Understatement
For a statement about the creator of the universe, calling God a 'good man' is a profound understatement. This stylistic choice grounds a cosmic truth in humble, everyday language.
Transcription
Quotations
God is holde a ryghtwys man.
There cam one which sayd that God was a good man.
He wyll say that God is a good man.
In the country, quoth he, where God is a good man.
It is good enough for mee to know, that God is a good man.
Shakespeare Citations
Well, God's a good man.
Explanation
[An old phrase for "God is good."]
Related Proverbs
Original Scan

Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.