The BEST may amend

Meaning & Analysis

Even what is judged the best can be improved—or be allowed to correct a fault.

Insights

Humility of excellence

Greatness is not immunity from error; the truly ‘best’ remains open to correction, treating perfection as a horizon rather than a finish line.

Permission to repent

Reads ‘may’ as leave rather than mere possibility: even the most upright should have room to make amends—an ethic of mercy that sustains communities.

Revisable institutions

Converts the maxim into policy: the finest laws, plans, or precedents should be amendable, because changing conditions expose hidden flaws.

Craft of revision

Excellence is iterative—drafts, proofs, prototypes all improve through emendation; the proverb dignifies the workshop of edits.

Anti-finality

Warns against declaring anything ‘finished’ simply because it is best so far; complacency is the enemy of renewal.

Modal nuance

Early English ‘may’ straddles possibility and permission. The proverb thus says both ‘can improve’ and ‘ought to be allowed to improve,’ blending prudence with charity.

Amend vs. emend

‘Amend’ covered repair of conduct and condition; in textual culture, ‘emendation’ corrected copyist errors. The saying inherits both the moral and scholarly habits of correction.

Social grace

Cultures that expect the ‘best’ never to err breed concealment; by normalizing amendment, the proverb encourages confession, accountability, and restored trust.

Growth mindset

Psychologically, it rebukes fixed standards: even elite performers refine through feedback, practice, and post-mortems—failure becomes input, not identity.

Cross-cultural echoes

Kin to ‘Even Homer nods’ and craftsmanly ideals like Japanese ‘kaizen’ (continuous improvement): mastery is maintenance, not monument.

Time-bound ‘best’

Superlatives are contextual; what is ‘best’ today ages into ordinary tomorrow. Amendment is how excellence keeps pace with changing needs.

Rhetorical Devices

Paradox

Yokes ‘best’ (a superlative implying sufficiency) to ‘amend’ (improvement), creating productive tension that invites reflection on perfection’s limits.

Modal ambiguity

The auxiliary ‘may’ carries both ability and permission, widening the proverb’s ethical and practical reach.

Ellipsis

Leaves unstated what is to be amended—behavior, text, plan—so the maxim applies across moral, legal, and technical domains.

Synecdoche (superlative)

‘Best’ stands for elites, top choices, or reigning standards, letting a single word address many hierarchies.

Aphoristic brevity

Compact, gnomic form gives it ready currency as counsel against complacency.

humilityimprovementfallibilityrevisiongrowthadaptability
Analyzed with gpt-5.0-thinking on November 14, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

1616, DR., no. 85
1659, N.R., p. 105

Original Scan

The BEST may amend - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026