Sup, SIMON, the best is at the bottom (here is good broth)

Meaning & Analysis

An encouragement to someone named Simon to finish his soup or broth, based on the idea that the most substantial and flavorful ingredients sink to the bottom of the bowl.

Insights

Perseverance and Reward

The proverb is a metaphor for perseverance, suggesting that enduring the initial, perhaps mundane or difficult, stages of an endeavor will ultimately lead to the most valuable and satisfying rewards.

Delayed Gratification

It advises patience and delayed gratification, teaching that the greatest benefits are often realized only after a period of sustained effort and waiting.

Hidden Value

The saying implies that true worth or quality is not always immediately visible. One must delve deeper or persist through the surface level to discover the most valuable aspects of a situation, person, or experience.

Optimistic Encouragement

As a form of optimistic encouragement, the proverb urges one to continue with a task by framing the final outcome as the most desirable part, thus inspiring persistence through challenges.

Culinary and Social Reality

Grounded in the simple culinary reality of hearty ingredients settling in a stew, the proverb reflects a common-sense observation from daily life. Its use of the generic, friendly name 'Simon' gives it a folksy, personal tone, as if offering direct encouragement to an everyman.

Psychology of Motivation

The proverb serves as a powerful tool for motivation, tapping into the psychological principle of delayed gratification. It frames perseverance not as mere endurance but as a journey toward a guaranteed and superior reward, making it a timeless piece of folk wisdom for encouraging effort.

Narrative Parallel

This saying encapsulates a common narrative trope found in folklore and literature: the hero's journey. The initial, less-exciting part of the task (the top of the broth) represents the trials and tribulations one must endure to reach the ultimate prize or discovery (the best at the bottom).

Rhetorical Devices

Direct Address

The use of a direct address to 'Simon' (an apostrophe) creates a personal, engaging, and immediate tone, as if giving advice in a specific, relatable context.

Metaphor

The act of eating broth serves as a simple yet effective metaphor for life's broader challenges and endeavors, where persistence leads to a final reward.

Imperative Mood

The opening 'Sup, Simon' is in the imperative mood, functioning as a gentle command or a strong piece of encouragement, which gives the proverb a proactive and motivational force.

perseverancerewardpatienceoptimismencouragementhiddenvalue
Analyzed with gemini-2.5-pro on November 26, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

Sup, Simon, now! eate Porridge for a month.

1607, Puritan, III, s. F1

(here's good broth).

1639, CL., Bibacitas, p. 46

('tis best i' th bottome.

Ibid.
1670, RAY, p. 217

Sup, Simon; very good broth.

1738, SWIFT, Pol. Conv., II, p. 437

Original Scan

Sup, SIMON, the best is at the bottom (here is good broth) - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026