I would it were in again with the HEDGEHOG after it

Meaning & Analysis

The speaker wishes a passed fart could be forced back inside—even if a prickly hedgehog followed it—an exaggerated way of expressing instant regret after an embarrassing, irreversible act.

Insights

Irreversibility of Actions

Like trying to put a fart back, some deeds cannot be undone; the proverb dramatizes the futility of wishing to reverse what is naturally one-way.

Costs of Impulse

Sudden, bodily impulse stands in for rash decisions: a moment’s release brings lasting embarrassment, underscoring the need for forethought.

Shame and Social Order

Public bodily mishaps symbolize breaches of decorum; the wish to ‘put it back’ reveals the pressure of social norms and fear of ridicule.

Punitive Wish-Fulfillment

Adding the hedgehog imagines a painful barrier to repetition—a fantasy of self-punishment meant to deter future lapses.

Words as Emissions

By analogy, spoken words—like gas—escape irretrievably; the proverb warns that ill-considered speech brings lasting consequences.

Grotesque Realism

The body-centered humor belongs to a long European tradition (jest books, tavern talk) where shameful functions voice serious truths: the body’s one-way processes mirror time’s arrow and moral causality.

Historical Register

Early modern English proverbial lore often used earthy images to moralize social tact; the hedgehog’s prickles sharpen the lesson, converting a comic slip into a cautionary emblem (cf. seventeenth-century proverb collections). :contentReference[oaicite:0]{index=0}

Psychology of Regret

The wish to reverse the act captures post-hoc counterfactuals and self-reproach: after a lapse, we recruit imaginary penalties to restore a sense of control and signal sincerity.

Speech Acts and Responsibility

As with ‘you cannot unring a bell,’ the proverb implies that agency persists after release: one owns the emission—of air or words—and must manage its social fallout.

Rhetorical Devices

Hyperbole

Invoking a hedgehog as the imagined ‘stopper’ wildly exaggerates the wish to undo the act, heightening comic shock and moral emphasis.

Grotesque Imagery

The vivid, bodily picture fuses embarrassment and pain, making the lesson unforgettable through visceral visualization.

Irony

The speaker’s wish is self-defeating: undoing a minor offense would entail greater pain—spotlighting the absurdity of retroactive fixes.

Euphemism-and-Reveal

The clipped ‘it’ coyly veils the fart, while the hedgehog bluntly exposes the scenario; the oscillation between decorum and bluntness enacts the very shame it describes.

Paradox

Desiring to reverse a natural, unrepeatable act frames a logical impossibility, sharpening the moral about acceptance and foresight.

regretirreversibilityhumorshameconsequencesbody
Analyzed with gpt-5.0-thinking on December 20, 2025

Transcription

Quotations

*A fart.

1659, HOW., Eng. Prov., p. 12

Original Scan

I would it were in again with the HEDGEHOG after it - a scanned entry from Tilley's 1950 Dictionary of Proverbs.
Scan courtesy of HathiTrust Digital Library.
Used under CC BY-NC 3.0.

© 2026 TilleyProverbs.com · About

Last updated: January 27, 2026